File-roller is a mess in my opinion, but it works. Until you start working with 4gb tar archives. Then everything goes downhill.
It copies the files into a temporary directory, even if the archive is not compressed. This makes adding files for the dvd backup a pain. The actual tar command decompresses very well, but I have not figured out how to add files without a gui.
Long story very short, it takes about an hour to open the archive, another to add files, no matter how small they are.